Is Semi-Automated Parking the Key to Density?

Is Semi-Automated Parking the Key to Density

Some version of automated parking in new developments is going to be integral to both creating density in L.A. and complying with the city’s parking requirements, as they slowly evolve. Automated parking is growing in popularity, but is still seeing slow adoption from real estate owners and developers. That is likely because there is little known about automated parking systems, both functionally and financially. Markwood Enterprises, an L.A. developer, has used fully automated parking systems in prior developments, but recently implemented semi-automated parking systems in two density-bonus developments, Dunsmuir Row in Mid-Wilshire and Elmwood Row in Larchmont.

Fully automated parking comes with a pretty price, and that price needs to be amortized over a significant amount of units or a very luxurious, expensive project. The price needs to be absorbed somehow” Simon M. Aftalion, development director at Markwood, tells “When you have smaller buildings, a fully automated system, which is the most efficient system in this realm of automated parking, doesn’t work. The Row projects are in a medium-density zone utilizing a density bonus, and packing on enough density to make one site pencil with 12 to 15 units. If we could evolve a plan set that really works, we can use that plan set again and again. The question was: how do we park them?

Markwood used semi-automated parking models to maximize the density on project and fulfill the CityLift Puzzle Systemparking requirements. Semi-automated parking includes a puzzle stacker in a typical parking structure that allows Markwood to nearly quadruple the parking spaces. “Within the realm of automated parking, there are puzzle-shift systems. It is a two-by-four grid that can shuffle similar to a parking stacker” says Aftalion. “We are building a parking lot in the semi-automated parking application. It still has a ramp and you still have a staircase and elevators. We use the same footprint as a garage but with a stacker, so in a space where you would have been able to build eight tandem spaces for four units, you can now have 14 spaces that are not dependent on a tandem system. Once you do that, you are able to pack on a larger size building and maximize what you would have otherwise been able to build.

In addition to maximizing the density on a project, the semi-automated system is also affordable for the development. Aftalion pegs the price of a semi-automated system at $12,000 to $14,000 per space. The fully automated system, he says, is approximately $2 million for the system, and then you have to dig out the basement for car storage. “The financials are site-specific, but regardless, they both make more sense than providing traditional parking. Both systems are wonderful” he explains.

While automated parking is a new trend, Aftalion says that it is only going to grow in popularity, especially as tenants get acquainted with the system. “I think that you will see the puzzle shift semi-automated system will probably come first throughout L.A. because it is more affordable and people tend to be more comfortable with a parking stacker” he says.

The Row projects are currently under construction and total 27 units—a mix of townhouses, one-bedrooms, two-bedrooms, studios and studio lofts, along with low-income units as required by the density bonus—on two lots totaling 37,323 square feet. With the semi-automated parking system, the two projects can park a total of 35 cars. The system has a retrieval time of 33 seconds.

About CityLift ParkingCityLift Parking logo

At CityLift Parking, we bring 30 years of automated parking lift experience around the globe to the US.  With offices around the country, our automated parking lifts span the full range of product choices.  We work closely with our customers to design the best parking layout for them, partner to get their project approved, install the systems, and stand by our products by providing ongoing service. We also offer financing through our banking partners so the capital expenditure can be metered over time.

For more information, visit our website at or email us at